Skip to content
Astamar

Dieser Artikel ist noch nicht übersetzt und wird auf Englisch angezeigt.

Tulum vs. Playa del Carmen: where to buy for rental income

Tulum earns higher nightly rates; Playa del Carmen is the steadier rental market. An honest look at the 2025–2026 numbers and what they mean for buyers.

Andrés Pérez
Andrés PérezVerfasst von
12. November 20263 Min. Lesezeit
Tulum vs. Playa del Carmen: where to buy for rental income

Tulum and Playa del Carmen sit 45 minutes apart on the same coast, share the same airport options and are both on the Tren Maya line. Yet as rental investments they behave very differently. I sell in both, and I live and work in Tulum — so here is the honest version.

The short answer

  • Playa del Carmen is the steadier choice: an established, walkable city with year-round residents, deeper demand and more predictable occupancy.
  • Tulum commands higher nightly rates and has the stronger brand, but it is working through a supply wave. Today it rewards buyers who negotiate hard and pick very carefully.

What the numbers say

Nightly rates favor Tulum. Using AirDNA data, Expansión reported in October 2025 an average Tulum short-term rental rate of about US$185 a night — roughly 27% above Playa del Carmen — with about 5,100 units in Tulum versus about 6,900 in Playa.

Occupancy has softened across the region, more in Tulum. The state’s vacation-rental managers association (APAR) put annual occupancy for the Mexican Caribbean at 47.6% in 2025, down from 49.5% in 2024, and pointed to oversupply. Tulum hotel occupancy fell from 73.8% in 2024 to 69.1% in 2025, according to Quintana Roo tourism-observatory figures reported by The LatInvestor.

The year-round base differs. Playa del Carmen is a real city with schools, hospitals and a large resident population. A large share of Tulum’s newer inventory was built as investment product rather than homes, which means more units chasing the same visitors in low season.

Palm-lined beach in Playa del Carmen
Playa del Carmen: walkable, year-round, and the more predictable rental market.

Playa del Carmen: the case for

  • Walkability. Quinta Avenida, the beach and the Cozumel ferry are all within reach — guests don’t need a car.
  • Broader demand. Families, repeat visitors, digital nomads and long-stay tenants all come here, which helps in shoulder months.
  • Long-term rental fallback. If short-term demand dips, there is a real market of local and expat tenants.
  • Watch for: new licensing rules. Playa del Carmen has been moving toward a mandatory license for vacation rentals. Confirm the rules for the specific building before you buy.

Tulum: the case for

  • Higher rates and a global brand. Design-led homes near cenotes, beach clubs and wellness retreats still command premium prices.
  • Better access than before. Tulum’s international airport (TQO) and the Tren Maya station have improved access.
  • Buyer’s market. With more inventory and softer occupancy, there is room to negotiate on price and terms — especially on finished resale units.
  • Watch for: unfinished infrastructure in some zones (roads, water, power), developer delivery risk on presales, and projections built on peak-season rates.

How to choose

  1. Stress-test the numbers. Model the rental at today’s occupancy, not a developer’s brochure. If it only works at 70%, it doesn’t work.
  2. Buy the micro-location, not the town. In Playa: walking distance to the beach and Quinta. In Tulum: Aldea Zamá and La Veleta with paved access and utilities, or Region 15 only with a long horizon.
  3. Prefer finished product. In both markets, a completed unit with a rental history beats a rendering.
  4. Check HOA rules and licensing for short-term rentals — in writing.
  5. Plan for management. Professionally managed units have been outperforming self-managed ones in this market.

Our view

If the goal is income stability, start in Playa del Carmen. If you want upside and a lifestyle property and can hold for the long term, Tulum offers some of the best negotiating leverage in years. Either way, buy the building and the block — not the headline.

Verwandte Einblicke

Kontakt

Sprechen Sie mit einem Astamar-Berater

Andrés Pérez

Ihr Berater

Andrés Pérez

Immobilienberater

Büro
Playa del Carmen · Tulum · Mérida · Puerto Vallarta · Tijuana